Wednesday, 11 March 2015

Education policy: Challenges of implementation By Prof. Quazi Faruque Ahmed

First of all it must be admitted that we have been able to formulate and work out an Education Policy after decades of polemics. Passed in the Bangladesh National Parliament on December 7, 2010, and thus known as National Education Policy 2010, it is a great leap forward in education. It may be mentioned here that the 18-member Education Policy Formulation Committee was formed on April 6, 2009 with National Professor Kabir Chowdhury and eminent economist Dr. Qazi Kholiquzzaman Ahmad as the Chair and Co-chair respectively; the committee submitted its report within four months. I am fortunate to be in a position to play a small role in the process, as a member of the Education Policy Formulation Committee. I have reasons to be happy for being inducted in the Education Policy Implementation and Monitoring Committee later as well. Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina made an unprecedented decision in involving policymakers in the implementation mechanism. Before formal adoption of the policy by the government, the draft policy was posted online at her instruction for open discussion and eliciting public opinion. This resulted in a positive outcome and the Education Policy this time was able to achieve wider acceptability in the country. Education Minister Nurul Islam Nahid also deserves appreciation for his proactive role all through the process. 


There are 30 aims, objectives, goals and principles mentioned in the Education Policy which include, among others: 
 To create a society free from the curse of illiteracy;
 To remove socio-economic discrimination in regards to race, religion and creed, and to eradicate gender disparity; to develop non-communalism, global fraternity, fellow-feeling and respect for human rights; 
 To give priority to primary and secondary education; to show students the dignity of labour; to enable them to acquire skills in vocational education and facilitate self-employment, irrespective of educational qualifications; 
 To ensure the proper context and situation in the education system at the higher level to facilitate the ideal environment for learning; 
 To ensure the education of the physically and mentally challenged learners. 
17 important steps regardless of the level of education are also suggested in NEP 2010, of which mention may be made of the following: 
 Gradually, programs have to be implemented at all level through the co-ordination of the demands for different levels of socio-economic manpower, educational qualification and expertise acquired through education.
 It is urgently required to free the educational institutions from the influence of party politics. To realise this objective, guidelines have to be prepared and strictly implemented. 
 It is necessary to prepare some code of conduct for the teachers and learners at all levels of education; they will be made aware of it accordingly. To do this, different and appropriate committees must be formed. It has to be ensured that students, at any level of education, do not face any physical or mental abuse. 
 Effective co-ordination of all levels of education and differential responsibilities for management of those levels will be in place. There will be an effective inter-ministerial coordination of work. 
Another progressive step recommended in the NEP is teaching common core subjects like Mathematics, Science, Bangladesh Studies, Environment and Climate Change in all streams at the primary level, including general, English medium, technical schools and madrasas. 
Continuity in education and reports
The question of continuity is very vital in education and there is little scope for placing completely new things in the world of knowledge. Not just anybody can write a book on Physics or Chemistry to satisfy his or her whim, ignoring the axioms and theories established through years of research and experimentation. This is the case with the education policy as well, which is for the most part a continuous process. Here, neither the past can be turned down nor new innovations can be disowned. The Qudrat-E-Khuda Commission Report of 1974 must be given due credit for its uniqueness, forward-looking ideas, in-depth analysis and concrete recommendations for the removal of malaise in almost all the tiers of education including disparity and discrimination. However, we find many things common in the education reports of Bangladesh. Not only the Qudrat-E-Khuda Education Commission Report, almost all the reports on education support the extension of primary school to the eighth grade and the introduction of pre-primary education, and stress on vocational/technical education. The reports in question include the Interim Education Policy of 1979, Mofizuddin Report of 1988, and Maniruzzaman Mia Report of 2003. In my view, the difference actually lies in the approach, which has been traditionally political in nature and has had concerns regarding implementability. In this regard, the initiative to thrash out the difference of opinion by the government led by Sheikh Hasina could achieve national consensus; no apparent discord or protest was also evident during the adoption of the NEP 2010. But many do not consider the question of implementation, particularly its progress, satisfactory.  


Photo: Star Archive

Challenges in implementation
As a member, I proposed in the first meeting of NEP Implementation Committee to constitute an independent body which would have a separate office either in the Ministry of Education or outside, like NAEM, managed by people other than government officials since they remain preoccupied with their normal work or are overloaded. Only secretarial services from government officials were sought. But the proposal did not receive due consideration.
The formulation of NEP was relatively more smooth because of openness in the process, valuable guidance from the Chair Prof. Kabir Chowdhury and the tireless efforts, rather round the clock engagement of the Co-Chair Qazi Kholiquzzaman Ahmad in maintaining both the timeliness and preciseness of the NEP draft. The services rendered by the then NAEM Director Sk. Ekramul Kabir also deserve mention; he helped the Co-chair especially in sorting out and copying the divergent proposals made by some thousand individuals and organisations. As members, some of us were given specific responsibilities such as preparing write-ups or draft on one or more particular topic. This was done to save time and to utilise our services in the required areas.
In regards to implementation, isolated actions, such as not linking NEP in the decisions of the government in the field of education, also reflect the lack of co-ordination. For this, not even the positive actions of the government could be circulated properly. Now that the slow pace of implementation of the NEP is under question, ascertaining coordination and fixing priorities is vital in the process. To mention a few: 
1. Passing of the Education Policy without any further delay;
2. Establishment of a permanent statutory Education Commission;
3. Formation of Teachers' Recruitment Authority;
4. Introduction of decent, attractive pay structure/separate payscale for teachers from primary to higher education levels.
Again the challenges that stand in the way of implementing the Education Policy must also be faced with courage and vision:
1. Appropriate allocation for education; 
2. Ending politicisation in education and the interference of vested quarters;
3. Linking the existing education system to the job market; 
4. Taking effective steps to keep a check on brain drain; 
5. Promoting science education; 
6. Establishing coordination in the management of education and educational institution; 
7.  Ensuring the process of monitoring in every tier and stage of education; 
8. Adopting effective measures to check corruption; 
9. Introducing proper pre- and in-service training for teachers; 
10. Ending corporal punishment of students at the hand of teachers. 
The Education Minister refers to debt servicing as a challenge to increase education budget, though he himself supports allocating 20 percent of the budget or 6 percent of the GDP to education. There are merits in his contention but the political will of the government is also considered no less important a phenomenon. Collection of revenue from utility services like the ongoing levy on mobile phones and other avenues like the CSR and the local self-government have also been suggested by members of the civil society. In connection to this, Rasheda K Choudhury, Executive Director of CAMPE and elected Board member of Global Campaign for Education (GCE), has rightly emphasised the need to strength participatory planning and accountability, the watchdog role of civil society in local level education governance, academic supervision, community engagement and monitoring. 



Education can be universal and transformative
Very recently I received a message from the office of Irina Bokova, the Director-General of UNESCO in response to my new year greeting which reads: “On behalf of the Director-General who is currently on an official visit abroad, thank you very much for sending these kind greetings for 2015. In return she has asked me to convey to you her warm wishes for good health, wellbeing and every success in taking forward your country's ambitious education and human development agenda. In the course of her visits, she has had the opportunity to witness first-hand the formidable commitment of your government to providing all children and youth with quality education and skills, and often cites the impressive results achieved, in particular with regard to overcoming gender disparities in education at primary and secondary levels, as proof that with political will at the highest level, the right policies and resources, Education can become universal and transformative.”
.........................................................................

The writer is the Chairman of Initiative for Human Development (IHD), a member organisation of Asia and South Pacific Association for Basic and Adult Education (ASPBAE). He can be reached at ihdbd@yahoo.com

BNP spokesman Salahuddin detained, claims wife

Star Online Report

BNP Joint Secretary General Salahuddin Ahmed has been picked up allegedly by law enforcers.
“Members of Rab, police and DB (Detective Branch of police) detained him from an Uttara residence at 10:10pm yesterday,” Salahuddin’s wife Hasina Ahmed told The Daily this afternoon.
However, law enforcers denied picking up the BNP leader who has been delivering his duties as the spokesperson of the party for more than a month.
Contacted, Masudur Rahman, deputy commissioner (Media) of Dhaka Metropolitan Police, said, “We have no information in this regard.”

Tuesday, 10 March 2015

Agriculture: Technology gives boost By Shahnoor Wahid

star

Source: star
In the last 40 years the amount of arable land has shrunk at a rate of 1 percent per annum. In the last 40 years many natural sources of irrigation water have dried up permanently. In the last 40 years saline water has crept up on vast tracts of agriculture land in some areas. In the last 40 years our population has doubled from 7.5 crore to over 15 crore. And yet, the country has been producing enough food-grains to feed the entire population. This is an amazing feat by any definition.
Only one thing can explain this phenomenon. Some kind of revolution has taken place in Bangladesh in the agriculture sector. It is true, that initially after the birth of Bangladesh, the sector was not finding the right directionfor some years. Food-grains had to be imported to supplement local production. There were pockets here and there in the country where draught brought misery to human life, but the governments of the day as well as non-government organisations jointly worked to not allow the situation to escalate to the level of a famine. Now, it is all in the past.
It is proper planning, relentless research by our agro-scientists, application of scientific knowledge, and timely financial and logistics support from the Ministry of Agriculture that made it possible to increase food production and feed such a huge number of people. The present government, during its tenures in the past and at present, gave top priority to the development of the agriculture sector as they were wise enough to realise that food on the plate was the very first thing people needed every day.Awami League, since its first term in 1996, found a very dynamic leader in Begum MotiaChowdhuty to lead this sector, who was far-sighted and who never hesitated to take radical decisions to develop the vital sector. The results soon started to become palpable enough to bring smiles on the faces of the farmers and everyone else involved in the business of agriculture. 
Today, we find stacks of rice sacks along with various other agriculture produce in the shops throughout the country. People get to buy staple food, cash crops and seasonal vegetables at an affordable price. We are also regularly exporting vegetables to Middle-Eastern countries. As said before, only proper planning ahead of each crop season with timely support coming in the form of fertiliser, water and seeds can ensure reaching the desired targets. The role of the Ministry of Agriculture and its affiliated organisations thus has to be orchestrated well in line with the mood of the climate and other natural and man-made conditions in order to have a good harvest.

Agriculture experts are confident that in 2015 total yields of all kinds of agriculture produce will not only reach but in some cases exceed the envisaged target. Already farmers are getting good harvests of wheat, maze, potato, sweet potato, pulses and mustard which exceed by far what they had expected before planting the seeds. There has also been bumper production of all sorts of vegetables in the past years in the country. December to January is the season for developing the boro rice seedlings and farmers have been successful in planting those in favourable weather. The target this season is to cultivate boro rice in 4.8 million hectares of land. The uninterrupted supply of electricity is helping farmers in getting the desired amount of irrigation water almost everywhere. Farmers reaped a good harvest of wheat this year which has generated greater keenness in them to grow more wheat again next season. Experts feel that if farmers continue to get all the support from the government the country will witness another agricultural revolution soon.
A number of factors worked behind the success in the agriculture sector, but experts believe the government policy to provide subsidies and support farmers through providing equipment and necessary materials like fertiliser at affordable prices, steady supply of irrigation water, high quality seeds, etc. are the prominent ones worth mentioning. There have been no major reports of pest attacks or various diseases so far that afflict crops and vegetables. Therefore, to feed 15 crore plus people regularly, it is doubly important to introduce innovative ideas, policies and technology for the development of the agriculture sector because no matter what, at the end of the day people will want food. And a government loses popularity fast if it cannot ensure food on everyone's table. For any Bangladeshi government this is supposed to be the scariest part of governance.


With this bleak reality looming before the Ministry of Agriculture, planning intelligently is the only option left to them.  More land has to be brought under cultivation of staple crops as well as cash crops, and the policy of providing subsidy to farmers has to be upheld. If we look at the statistics, the present government did take care of these factors since coming to power in 2008. It reduced the price of DAP to Tk 27, from Tk 85; MOPto Tk 15 from Tk 70; TSP to Tk 22 from Tk 80. The government took the decision to reduce the price of non-urea fertiliser and of phosphatic fertiliser and potash in three instalments. What is more amazing is that the country exported some varieties of seedlings and also some scented rice in 2014.
Minister for Agriculture, Motia Chowdhury said last year in a meeting of economists that if the government had not given subsidy to farmers, the country would have had no option left but to import rice. She also said that giving 25 percent subsidy to mechanisation has helped in solving the problem of farm labour to a great extent. Referring to adoption and application of latest crop science and technology in the agriculture sector, the minister had commented, “If our agro scientists had not developed high yielding varieties of crops like rice and wheat, it would have been difficult to ward off famine in the country. Though our scientists have developed varieties of crops, the sense of direction changes with the change of government. At such times scientists feel at a loss. If a scientific project is not allowed to continue then it creates problems for the scientists and the country in the long run.  In 1996 I saw BR 11, and coming back six years ago saw the same BR 11. That means no better variety has been developed and marketed since then. That means if the scientific research works are not brought forward by the government and the private sector, we shall face problems.
The world food growers will not feed us with their excess production. Food aid has also reduced. WFP gives money with instruction to buy our own food. We buy food from internal sources and give it to the poor. We do not get food from outside. Countries producing excess crops are going for biofuel. They will not sell or give that excess crop but will use it as biofuel. This is the global reality today. Therefore, whoever is in power has to pay attention to research and development and increase funding. My request to those in industrialisation is to come forward and help in R&D in agriculture.”

Regarding labour market she said the following in the economic forum: “I believe the solution is in mechanisation and arranging capital for farmers. The government is doing this with great farsightedness. Our farmers have cards now; they can open a bank account with only Tk 10 with that card and can get agricultural loan for farming seasonal crops. One thing I want to mention is that the system of taking loan from mahajons against interest no more exists in the rural areas. The mahajoni loan system abolition was possible through introducing this card and opening of bank accounts. Through these accounts we can know how many people want to take agriculture loans, how many utilise it properly and what is the actual need. In the last four years no one reported anything on mohajoni loan. It was possible because of this government's well-planned strategy.
Our scientists are doing research work on temperature tolerant, stress tolerant and salinity tolerant wheat. As a result we are going for wheat cultivation in Faridpur, Shariatpur, Madaripur and Barguna. We introduced maize (bhutta) cultivation after the floods of 1988. I want to say that we are open-minded about GMO. As a result, BT Brinjal is now available in the market.”
It may be mentioned here that the specialty of Bt Brinjal is that the farmers do not need to spray pesticides on it.Usually, farmers have to spray pesticides up to 80 times in a cropping season of brinjal against a recommended dose of 25, making the vegetable highly toxic. The new varieties developed by the scientists of Bari are: Bari Bt (Uttara), Bari Bt (Kajla), Bari Bt (Nayontar) and ISD006 BtBari.
During the distribution of the plants among the farmers at Bangladesh Agriculture Research Centre, the Agriculture Minister said, “We have decided to start cultivating B tBrinjal after different necessary tests at home and abroad. We took a long time to experiment all pros and cons for introducing the cultivation of this variety”.  She emphasised the necessity of introducing GMO crops to ensure food security of the people but ensured that the government is always alert of any kind of negative reaction to public health and the environment. It took seven years to complete greenhouse trials and open-field trials of Bt Brinjal in various agro-ecological zones in the country. Bt gene insertion in brinjal makes it resistant to fruit and shoot borer (FSB) that causes 50 to 70 percent loss of brinjal yield. With the journey of cultivating BtBrinjal, Bangladesh has joined a group of 29 countries that grow GM crops.
The minister further told the meeting that the soybean oil we are using is pure GMO. In her words, “GMO is the future of our agriculture. We are also doing GMO with two varieties of potatoes to save them from late blight disease. Let me add one more thing, bananas will become GMO too. We shall take forward scientific research and mechanisation and we shall give required capital to the farmers. Besides rice and wheat, our oil seed production has increased, we are giving loans at 4 percent interest to farmers to grow spices, onions, garlic, turmeric, gingeretc.
Let's try to visualise agriculture in future. Agriculture will not be dominant in the northern part for long. Looking at the number of land ports, electricity production, road network etc. there will be more industrialisation there. As the agriculture minister in 1996, I used to procure rice from Mymensingh. Now Mymensingh is not in the list of sources for rice procurement. Dhaka has now extended up to Mymensingh. Future of agriculture lies in the south, whether it's cereal, crop agriculture, vegetable, or aqua culture. The problem in the south is salinity, tidal surge, and water logging in some places. This government will discourage boro cultivation in the upland. It takes 3,200 litres of water to produce 1 kg of boro rice, so we cannot support this. We shall encourage boro in mono crop areas like haor areas with availability of surface water. We have heard about rain-fed aman crop cultivation. We have turned away from aush rice because of boro. Aush is stress- tolerant and it requires little water. Rice is being harvested in Bangla months of Aghrayan and Poush. But what about where there is no boro? Aush used to come between boro and aman as an intermediary crop. When there is no rain we may go for supplementary irrigation, for a little period.  I have asked our scientists in BRRI to work with aush rice so that it can come as a crop in between the two. So, with aman, boro and aush we shall fill our cereal food basket.  Also we shall produce wheat and maize.” There is no denying the importance of agriculture for a country burdened with a huge population  but having limited natural resources. The government will have to allocate the required finds for the development of climate-tolerant rice, wheat, pulses, corn and vegetables. There can be no hesitation or policy lapse in providing farmers full support on the fields during each crop season because loss of one crop will take us back to square one. We cannot take any risk with our agriculture.


The writer is Editor, Special Supplements, The Daily Star.


Published: 12:00 am Tuesday, March 10, 2015

AD BANNAR